By CHARLES LUNAN
More than 75,000 manufacturing jobs lost in two years, with more
to come.
Rising unemployment.
Tightfisted consumers and businesses.
Rising vacancy rates, personal bankruptcies and foreclosures.
The threat of another terrorist attack.
It hardly sounds like a recipe for economic recovery, but that's
what lies ahead in 2001, according to most economic forecasts.
The consensus among economists is that gross domestic product - a
broad measure of U.S. economic activity - will resume growing in the
second quarter. By the fourth quarter, the nation's economy could be
back on track for 5.4 percent annual growth, according to DRI-WEFA,
an economic forecasting firm in Boston. Some economists think the
recession is already over, thanks to a powerful combination of low
interest rates, falling energy prices and a rising supply of cash.
The torrent of negative news from Carolinas manufacturers over
the last two years has obscured a significant fact: Although the two
states lost 69,500 manufacturing jobs in the year ended Oct. 31,
about 3,100 more people were working in both states than were
working a year earlier.
That number illustrates just how much the area's economy is
changing.
Despite the continued decline of the apparel, textile and
furniture industries and a deep contraction in the technology
sector, growth in the services industry in Charlotte and the
Triangle and the tourism industry in South Carolina have put the
regional economy on a solid footing for a second-quarter rebound.
The key to the pace of that recovery will be consumer confidence,
which is higher than during either the 1981-82 or 1990-91
recessions. Americans who still have jobs seem to have moved past
the paralyzing fear caused by the events of Sept. 11, although it's
anyone's guess what will happen if there is another terrorist
attack.
Americans seem more guided by their own financial outlook. Many
know someone who has lost a job or closed a business. Others have
had their salaries frozen or their bonuses cut. More are still
waiting for the ax to fall at work.
If prior recessions are any guide, many Americans will deal with
the anxiety by hunkering down and paying off credit-card debt,
eschewing borrowing until their prospects improve.
Typical is Bonnie Green. The lowest mortgage rates since the
1960s persuaded the mother of two and her husband to buy a house
this year, but she vowed not to use her credit cards to finance
holiday shopping.
"I'm mostly paying cash," said Green, who drove from
her home in Concord this month to snap up deeply discounted clothing
at a JC Penney Outlet store in Charlotte. "I don't want to have
bills after Christmas."
Like many Americans, she is willing to spend money improving her
home. She has taken advantage of no-interest loans at Best Buy and
Home Depot.
"That's a gift to myself," she said of some window
shades she bought for her home. "It's rough everywhere, but you
can't stop living."
Sociologists have speculated that many Americans, in the wake of
the terrorist attacks, are shifting their focus to the home as part
of what they term the "nesting effect." As a result, Best
Buy and Home Depot and Lowe's are among the only nationwide
retailers to report healthy sales gains in November.
But like politics, all economics is local. The outlook is grim
for hundreds of workers laid off from apparel or furniture jobs in
Gaston or Davidson counties. As of November, the number of people
who had exhausted their unemployment benefits in North Carolina had
swelled nearly 94 percent from a year earlier to 20,422, according
to the Center for Budget Priorities and Policy, a Washington, D.C.,
think tank. Only Oregon and South Dakota reported higher jumps.
South Carolina saw an 84 percent increase.
Layoffs, particularly in manufacturing, will likely increase in
the coming quarter even if the economy rebounds. Between March and
November, the number of jobs lost nationwide was less than one
percent, far less than the levels of 1.4 to 3 percent in prior
recessions. That suggests the United States could lose another
600,000 jobs next year after losing 2.6 million from October 2000
through Nov. 30.
Then again, this recession has been unlike prior downturns in so
many ways, particularly in the Carolinas.
It is the first recession in recent memory triggered by a
manufacturing decline rather than a housing and real estate
slowdown. And although manufacturing led the Carolinas into
recession, it is unlikely it will lead them out.
Even more than consumers, manufacturers are cutting back, despite
low interest rates. Many borrowed heavily in the 1990s to expand
capacity, only to mothball equipment when the economy declined.
Moreover, many of their customers have planned to cut back
spending next year. For instance, BellSouth and most other telephone
companies have shaved their capital budgets by 15 to 20 percent,
which amounts to billions of dollars not spent on network upgrades
next year.
As a result, many technology industries are making fewer
products, relative to the amount of machinery they own, than they
have at any time since the government began keeping capacity
statistics in the 1940s. In Catawba County, fiber optics
manufacturers have idled 1,800 workers this year and are not sure if
or when they will call them back. While inventories have declined
significantly, manufacturers will continue cutting jobs and will be
less likely to refill them when the economy does rebound because of
gains in productivity.
The good news is that the Carolinas are much less dependent on
manufacturing than they were during the last recession. Also,
interest rates are much lower and consumer confidence is much
higher.
In rapidly growing markets such as Charlotte and the Triangle,
it's hard to find a businessperson who is not convinced the economy
will come roaring back in the next few quarters. Charlotte is
expected to grow by another 193,000 people this decade, or slightly
more than it did in the '90s. Roughly 70 percent of them will be
relocating from outside the county.
"We just don't believe in recessions," said Allen Tate,
chairman of Allen Tate Realtors, which is building four offices to
keep up with growth in downtown Charlotte and its increasingly
far-flung suburbs. "National statistics don't mean too much to
us."
Consumer pessimism has been tempered by the lowest interest rates
in 40 years and the growing realization that the frantic bull market
and economic growth in recent years were an aberration.
For those who feel secure in their jobs, times could not be
better to buy a car or home. Even those who stay put are benefiting
by refinancing their mortgages.
New-home starts accelerated in November, rising 5 percent above
their year-ago level. In Charlotte and the Triangle, expect housing
starts and values to remain strong in the $80,000 to $300,000 price
range, even as commercial developers pull back to let millions of
square feet of retail and office space be absorbed.
In the Triad and smaller towns, where many of the nearly 70,000
manufacturing jobs were lost, the economy will get worse before it
gets better. Economic forecasters at DRI-WEFA don't see the
unemployment rate peaking until the second quarter in North Carolina
and the third quarter in South Carolina.
In the Hickory-Morganton-Lenoir metropolitan area, where
unemployment more than doubled this year to 7.1 percent following
several plant closings, city leaders are anxiously recruiting new
employers. The 13-county region that includes Charlotte had a 5.7
percent unemployment rate.
"Now the big water and sewer users are gone," said
Barry Stock, a commercial real estate broker on Morganton's
redevelopment commission. "Somebody has got to pay those
bills."
Replacing those jobs will be a tall order, but on the whole,
growth will return to the Carolinas next year, economists believe.
It will have to - to accommodate the 2.5 million more people
expected to live here by 2010.