Worthy investment
Historic barn perfect as new home for trolley
The Charlotte Trolley, already a welcome attraction with an
ever-growing fan base, needs a permanent home. And if money is not found
soon, it will likely lose the chance to get one with deep historic
significance.
That would be a shame. Housing the Charlotte Trolley at the Duke Power
streetcar barn could only enhance the trolley as both history and
transportation. The barn was the site of a little known historic event in
the city - a 1919 labor strike where five trolley conductors were killed.
Planners want the barn for the centerpiece of a retail and residential
village to be called Manchester on South Boulevard. But $4 million is
needed to buy and renovate the structure. Promised help from a would-be
benefactor fell through a year ago, and so far no other donor has been
found.
The trolley will have to move - even if it can't locate at the old Duke
Power barn. The developer has other plans for its current location in the
Atherton Mill near South End Brewery, and it will outgrow that site
anyway. There are plans for a museum and full-scale daily streetcar
service.
Dan Morrill of the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Historic Landmarks Commission
calls it a lost opportunity if the city doesn't capitalize on the historic
connections of locating at the Duke Power site. "The trolley is
already making Charlotte a different place, but for it to have its full
impact, it has to be at this location," he aptly noted.
He's right. As the site of the worst labor violence in Charlotte's
history, the place ripples with emotional undercurrents. On Aug. 25, 1919,
members of the Amalgamated Association of Street and Electric Railway
Workers of America had been on strike for two weeks, seeking higher pay
and union recognition against the Southern Public Utilities Co., a
forerunner of Duke Power.
Gunfire erupted after more than 2,000 people gathered, including armed
strikebreakers and police. Five people died. Citizens were issued guns and
put on patrol. Troops were sent in. And a "no-man's-land" was
declared around the trolley barn, with a machine gun set up amid a pile of
sandbags on South Boulevard.
This is history worth remembering.
Historian Morrill suggests that the county use $1.3 million in bond
money designated for land acquisition to buy the trolley barn. The trolley
company - a private enterprise - could then lease and buy it. The city
could renovate the structure.
We think those ideas should become part of a larger public discussion
about the long-term future of a service that has become a welcome public
amenity. The city spent more than $20 million building trolley tracks. It
would be a shame for the service to fail because officials were too
shortsighted to see the value of further investment. |